The idea of ultimate sustainability behind the “No impact man” is definitely important – the amount of things we consume, directly or indirectly, and the amount of waste we produce, are abominable. I really liked the initiative, although I think it was in many ways too extreme. We can not just reject hundreds of years of all progress and commodities that the humanity came up with to make our lives easier and explore new possibilities, and that was to a great extent what the No Impact Man was doing. Simply rejecting electricity, or services like eating out, is not a solution, or at least – not a very clever one. It only makes the life of the person who decides to do it harder. Instead, new solutions of sustainable energy and transportation should be invented. In fact, they already have been invented, but they are more expensive, and it is not in the interest of big corporations to “bother” to switch to more sustainable resources. I think the No Impact Man was really making it hard on himself, instead of trying to find solutions that would actually work for larger numbers of people, ideally – with very little or none of there people’s effort. The way of life he proposed was actually taking a lot of time and effort, and as idealist as I am, I think people are generally seeking the easiest and most effortless ways to do things (although he did save a lot of time by not having a TV, for sure). I admire his effort and it was a good call towards raising awareness and bringing the family closer together. In the long run, however, if everybody lived this way, it would kind of slow the progress, if not throw us back, in my opinion. Therefore, like I said, I think we should look for alternative solutions, instead of ridding ourselves of the long-achieved comforts.
I also think, however, that there are certain things that we can do indeed. For example, we should shop locally, use bikes or public transportation as much as we can, get rid of paper billing and paper magazines (especially that now we do have easily accessible electronic versions), use reusable cups and tumblers, and stop buying bottled water. Reducing packaging waste, recycling, and composting (if possible) are also some brilliand and easily executable ideas. Overall, I think it was an interesting project and we should be more mindful of the environment (DUH!!!), but some radical solutions that were proposed in the movie could be done better.
I’m attaching a thought-provoking image about our impact on the planer and ourselves
http://www.upworthy.com/great-advice-for-aliens-that-want-to-destroy-earth